Publisher tool certifications and SAM tool selection

17 May 2016
3 minute read
Best practice

Publisher tool certifications and SAM tool selection

17 May 2016
3 minute read
Oracle and IBM tool verification - a club nobody can join

Oracle and IBM tool verification – a club nobody can join

During my current review of 10 SAM Tools for large enterprises – the issue of publisher certification has been raised.

This is when a software publisher gives their blessing for the quality of data or output from a SAM tool. See the original call for participants here.

This article provides an independent opinion on the matter and perhaps some guidance for ITAM Review reader when selecting tools.

Question: Should I consider the Oracle LMS tool verification when selecting a SAM Tool?

Answer: No.

Oracle has verified seven tools that “provide the required data set to supplement a LMS engagement”. But the program has a few flaws. Namely, sources inside Oracle tell us the whole program is on ice with 50 tools in the queue waiting to be verified. It’s hardly fair to discount a technology that is not verified when it is not possible to be verified. So rather than a benchmark, it’s a special club. So it should be disregarded as a program. This is unfortunate as vendor blessings are good thing, Oracle should be congratulated for introducing the program but now needs to get off the fence and either develop it or junk it.

Question: How should I prove whether the SAM tool is fit for purpose for managing Oracle?

Get your prospective SAM tool to demonstrate it working and delivering value either as a POC or as a low cost project. Populating the Oracle worksheet using their data would be a good first hurdle. Showing compliance and optimization / re-architecture opportunities for high-risk titles would be even better.

See also:

Question: Should I consider IBM verification when selecting a SAM tool?

Answer: No.

We were pleased to see IBM potentially following Oracle in verifying tools.

Unfortunately

  • There is no program that we are aware of and….
  • There is no public record of the program or process.

Again, if nobody can join it’s not a good basis for tool selection and should be discounted.

ITAM Review readers tell us you can get approval to use Flexera in substitute of ILMT for measuring sub-capacity with permission from IBM. But I’ve also heard of ITAM Review readers getting permission for other tools. So unfortunately this program (if indeed it is a program), along with Oracle, has become a bit of a farce.

This is a shame because this sort of guidance, verification and standards setting from publishers would be most welcome.

So for this reason I won’t be using vendor verifications as a competitive differentiator to discriminate between tools. Stay tuned to The ITAM Review newsletter to be notified when the review of 10 tools for Enterprise SAM is published.

About Martin Thompson

Martin is the founder of ITAM Forum, a not-for-profit trade body for the advancement of IT Asset Management.

He is also the author of the book "Practical ITAM - The essential guide for IT Asset Managers", a book that describes how to get started and make a difference in the field of IT Asset Management. In addition, Martin developed the PITAM training course and certification.

Connect with Martin on LinkedIn.

Can’t find what you’re looking for?

  • news post 1 Resources

    An Introduction to Scope 4 Emissions

    Executive Summary For ITAM teams, sustainability is a core responsibility and opportunity. Managing hardware, software, and cloud resources now comes with the ability to track, reduce, and report carbon emissions. Understanding emission scopes—from direct operational emissions ...
    Read More
  • news post 1 AI

    AI and ITAM: State of Play 2024 Research Report

    In 2024, the ITAM Forum and General Interfaces conducted a global survey (On behalf of the ITAM Forum’s AI+ITAM Working Group) targeting ITAM practitioners, executives, and stakeholders to explore the growing influence of AI on the ...
    Read More
  • news post 1 ITAM News & Analysis

    Will 'Sustainable IT' be Caught in the Crossfire?

    In the days immediately following his inauguration, President Trump and his team declared war on Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs at the federal level. The impact has been felt far and wide. Many government contractors ...
    Read More
  • news post 1 AI

    Are we ready for outcome-based pricing?

    When I first joined the ITAM industry (which feels like a million years ago), the predominant licensing metric in the market was per device. So, if you have three devices, you need three licenses. Then, with ...
    Read More